"Want to know if artificial intelligence is going to eliminate millions of jobs? The first place to look is the industry that birthed the technology.
AI seems set to do to computer programming what automation has done to other jobs, from the factory floor to the warehouse, the checkout aisle to the call center. In those industries, the end result of widespread automation has been the elimination of countless roles -- and their replacement with ones that require either relatively little skill and knowledge, or a great deal more, with workers at either end of this spectrum being rewarded accordingly.
Economists call this "skills-biased technological change." It's what happens when technology makes skilled workers more productive, while taking over the complex and difficult parts of more repetitive jobs, making workers who do them easier to train and more interchangeable.
Now, AI is automating so-called knowledge work, and the implications for the half of the U.S. workforce who are employed in such jobs are profound. It's true that these white-collar roles have been evolving for decades as technology has improved, but the elimination of middle-skilled jobs seems set to accelerate as AI is institutionalized in the workplace.
Tech layoffs over the past year, driven by macroeconomic trends, happen to have come just as genuinely useful AI for coding has arrived. For many young coders, the timing is unfortunate. Data from workforce-analytics company Revelio Labs indicate that companies have tended to fire their newest employees, and that in 2023, software engineers represent the largest share of people laid off by tech companies. The few tech job openings that remain, meanwhile, are being snapped up by still-in-demand, more-experienced software engineers.
"If I were an investor, and my companies were thinking about hiring hundreds of engineers, I'd say, well, maybe instead you can use AI to be more productive," says Prashanth Chandrasekar, chief executive of Stack Overflow, a company that maintains a user-generated repository of questions and answers for programmers.
Since the spring, investors have been piling into stocks perceived as being at the forefront of the AI boom, such as Nvidia, Advanced Micro Devices, Apple and Meta Platforms.
On one hand, these companies will have to continue hiring developers with skills in building AI. These engineers are currently the best-paid and the most in-demand, says Josh Brenner, CEO at Hired, a tech-jobs marketplace founded in 2013.
On the other hand, there's Braintrust.
The worker-owned talent network represents about 360,000 freelance developers, and counts Nike, Meta and Google among its more than 1,500 clients. CEO Adam Jackson aims to double Braintrusts' revenue in the next two years, without adding a single employee.
The company is building its own internal AI, trained on all of its job postings and developer resumes -- and the successful matches between the two. This system will take over more of the work of matching companies seeking developers with those freelancers, says Jackson. It will use many of the same technologies that make possible other generative AIs, like ChatGPT.
"That productivity creates more value for our network of engineers," he says. "It came out of nowhere thanks largely to AI."
Other industry- and company-specific AIs are likely to be built and used in a variety of workplaces. Anytime you're creating an online marketplace to match two parties -- whether that's home buyers and sellers, or ride-hailing drivers and riders -- AI is a way to increase productivity without adding to your company's head count, says Jackson.
Many experienced developers I spoke with expressed skepticism about the ability of AI coding tools to take over the most essential tasks of programming, including designing solutions to complex problems, and understanding existing libraries of code at companies that have been building up their systems for years, or even decades.
That said, those who are already using such systems think they could eliminate the need for certain tasks that are generally handed off to inexperienced and early-career programmers.
"Simple off-the-shelf issues can be tackled relatively easily now," says Jerome Choo, head of growth at AI-enabled, business-focused search startup Diffbot.
Indeed, the job- and wage-polarizing effects of automation on industries have often interrupted the usual ladder of hiring and development, warns Yossi Sheffi, a professor of engineering at Massachusetts Institute of Technology whose latest book is on the future of work. In manufacturing, that has meant some countries, including Germany, have created a dual education system that pushes people to do both apprenticeship and university study within the typical four years of college.
With automation finally coming for knowledge work -- in the form of AI -- a similar rethinking of employment and education for early-career white-collar workers might be necessary, he says.
In Stack Overflow's survey of developers, there's a difference between how experienced and junior coders said they use AI code-completion tools, like GitHub Copilot and ChatGPT. While experienced programmers said their No. 1 reason for using such tools is productivity, junior programmers said their primary use was for education -- that is, to absorb what the AI already knows.
When discussing the pace at which automation can push people out of a job, one of the historical examples Dr. Sheffi likes to cite is the telephone network.
In 1892, AT&T invented the first automatic telephone exchange, says Dr. Sheffi. "But in 1950, there were still 350,000 telephone exchange operators. Only in 1980 did the job basically disappear."
One reason we tend to overestimate the pace of technological change in the short term is that we fail to appreciate just how many forces stand in the way of a specific technology becoming widespread. Those forces can include unions, government regulation and social acceptability. With today's AI, Dr. Sheffi sees history repeating itself. Already, for example, there are proposals for a new federal agency to oversee the rollout of new technology platforms, including AI.
No matter how rapid the pace of development of AI, it's still up to humans to adopt the technology -- and in the course of individual human lives, we tend to change slowly, if at all.
That said, the double bind that many earlier-career developers currently find themselves in is a cautionary tale for us all. If AI disrupts a field at the same time that workers in it face other challenges, no matter what historians say, the impact of automation on jobs, and those who hold them, can be swift." [1]
In order to preserve income, after the loss of middle-skilled jobs due to technology, it is worth considering emigrating from countries such as Lithuania (where trade unions have zero influence) to countries such as Sweden (where trade unions are strong) or Germany (where there are usually so-called "labor councils" to negotiate wages, representing all employees of the company).
1. EXCHANGE --- Keywords: The New AI Software That's Eating the Software Industry --- Tech companies are turning to artificial intelligence to save money on computer programmers. Is your white-collar job next? Mims, Christopher.
Wall Street Journal, Eastern edition; New York, N.Y. [New York, N.Y]. 01 July 2023: B.5.
