Chinese President Xi Jinping invoked the "Thucydides Trap" during a high-stakes summit with U.S. President Donald Trump in Beijing. The theory suggests that when an emerging power threatens to displace an established one, the resulting tension and anxiety often lead to war.
The historical and geopolitical context of Xi's warning to Trump involves several key points:
• The Core Concept: Coined by Harvard political scientist Graham Allison, the term is based on the ancient Greek historian Thucydides, who wrote that the fear caused by the rise of Athens made the Peloponnesian War with Sparta inevitable.
• The Strategic Warning: During their May meeting, Xi directly asked Trump if the two nations could transcend this trap to establish a new paradigm for relations, framing China as a rising power and indicating that the U.S. should not fear their growth.
• The Taiwan Leverage: Xi explicitly warned Trump that the Taiwan question is the most important issue in bilateral relations and that mishandling it could push both nations into a highly perilous conflict.
“BEIJING -- President Trump's state visit to China ended Friday with both sides hailing a reset in relations, but each side signaled a starkly different idea of what that means.
Trump sought to open China's market to U.S. business and reciprocal trade -- reviving a policy he scrapped in his first presidency -- though the U.S. president left Beijing without offering concrete details of any trade agreements.
Chinese leader Xi Jinping, meanwhile, wanted "strategic stability" -- a predictable relationship in which Washington doesn't impede Beijing's economic and geopolitical rise. Trump said longstanding U.S. policy on Taiwan -- ambiguity over independence for the democratic, self-governed island -- remains the same.
"Nothing's changed. I will say this. I'm not looking to have somebody go independent," Trump said in an interview with Fox News.
"I want China to cool down," Trump said, saying he isn't looking for the U.S. to "to travel 9,500 miles to fight a war."
The shared desire for stable relations is a change after years of mutual antagonism.
"'Strategic stability' from strategic rivalry is a major shift," said Henry Wang, founder and president of the Beijing-based Center for China and Globalization. "We are moving to a new normal. This summit was an inflection point after a tough relationship that began with the start of Trump."
Under the surface, however, there remains an intense rivalry that holds the potential to disrupt the world stage, despite the bonhomie of the two-day visit.
China is boldly pressing its claims on Taiwan, and its military is becoming increasingly aggressive in the Western Pacific, rattling U.S. allies and posing a serious military and geopolitical challenge to Washington. And China's support of Iran -- an issue Trump raised during his visit -- could undermine U.S. efforts to force the regime to give up its nuclear program and halt its aggression in the Middle East.
Such disagreements didn't cool Trump's show of admiration for a man he repeatedly called his friend. Trump marveled at his reception, from a grand welcome ceremony to a Day Two stroll through the Chinese leadership compound in Beijing.
Throughout the visit, Xi sought to present China as a global power that is quickly closing the gap with the U.S. despite what it sees as efforts by multiple U.S. administrations to contain its rise.
Trump, a Republican, said he was "very impressed."
"The relationship is a very strong one," the president said Friday at the leadership compound in the heart of Beijing.
On trade, Trump said on Air Force One that U.S. farmers would be happy with China's purchases of U.S. soybeans. Trump said he and Xi discussed lifting sanctions on Chinese companies that buy Iranian oil.
His one detailed announcement during the visit, that China would buy 200 Boeing aircraft -- fewer than the expected 500 -- led the company's stock to fall 3.8%.
The broad takeaway in Beijing was that Trump and Xi both sought an end to a 10-year era in which the U.S. sought to blunt economic and security threats from China.
Trump, for instance, in a Fox News interview in Beijing played down concerns about China's espionage and theft of U.S. intellectual property, and floated the idea of the U.S. allowing more Chinese students -- where his administration once threatened to expel them.
Xi wants more predictability out of Trump, in particular on trade. U.S. tariffs have hit a key pillar of its growth when some in China were already questioning Xi's handling of the economy.
But for Xi, Taiwan is the most important issue -- and one that could ultimately make or break the relationship with the U.S. Xi said Thursday that any mishandling of tensions over the island, a self-governing democracy Beijing wants to control, could spark an "extremely dangerous situation" -- a nod to the potential for a great-power war.
On the flight back to the U.S., Trump said Xi "does not want to see a fight for independence because that would be a very strong confrontation."
But the president played down the risk of such a conflict. He said he wouldn't tell Xi whether the U.S. would defend Taiwan, later adding: "The last thing we need right now is a war."
China wants concessions from the U.S. on Taiwan, including small but crucial rhetorical shifts such as moving from not supporting Taiwanese independence to publicly opposing it, while also limiting weapon sales to the democratic self-governed island.
Xi also hailed ties with the U.S., in effect arguing that China's rise didn't pose a threat to the U.S.
"Achieving the great rejuvenation of the Chinese nation and making America great again can go hand in hand," Xi said at a state dinner for Trump on Thursday.
The turnaround was months in the making. Last year, the U.S. imposed tariffs on China -- some rising higher than 100% -- prompting Beijing to restrict exports of rare-earth materials. Trump and Xi in October brokered a trade detente in South Korea that slashed the tariffs.
But after China restricted the exports of the rare earths that are crucial for some U.S. manufacturing, many in Beijing have sensed a shift in how Trump approaches the relationship. "China couldn't punch back a decade ago. But now if the U.S. plays hardball, China can play hardball, too," Wang said.
In recent months, Trump told aides not to derail plans for the Xi summit and labeled the U.S.-China partnership as the "G-2," suggesting that the superpowers effectively dominated the world stage. China, reading the signs, saw the summit as a chance to assert itself.
"They are trying to lock in a truce, albeit one favorable to them," said Rush Doshi, who worked on China in former President Joe Biden's National Security Council, referring to China. "They want to lock it in beyond Trump, or use the Trump detente as the baseline for the future."
It will take more than momentary camaraderie for Washington and Beijing to change course.
Trump, despite his friendly tone toward China, still leads an administration that is tough on Beijing.
In recent weeks, the U.S. placed sanctions on Chinese entities suspected of aiding Iran's targeting of U.S. bases in the Middle East and accused Beijing of stealing artificial-intelligence technology from U.S. companies. The Justice Department continues to charge people, including U.S. politicians, who are alleged to have illegally aided China.
And the war in Iran and U.S. commitments to Taiwan could derail any intended progress, having already clouded a summit centered on economics and trade.
Trump came to Beijing looking for China to pressure Iran, which largely relies on China for its economic survival, to give in to U.S. demands and agree to an end to the conflict.
During the summit, Trump suggested he and Xi saw eye-to-eye on Iran, noting Beijing agreed that ship traffic through the Strait of Hormuz should be free and Tehran should never get a nuclear weapon. But China's Foreign Ministry issued a mid-summit statement with the blunt message that the war should never have been started in the first place.
Both Trump and Xi are scheduled for another summit on Sept. 24 in the White House, and they might also speak to one another on the sidelines of two international gatherings this year.” [1]
1. Trump, Xi Hail Reset After Summit --- Choreographed visit masks differences, as both sides seek to stabilize relations. Ward, Alexander; Spegele, Brian; Linskey, Annie; Wei, Lingling. Wall Street Journal, Eastern edition; New York, N.Y.. 16 May 2026: A1.
Komentarų nėra:
Rašyti komentarą